Just Friday one of my students showed me his recently
purchased smart phone. After
saying how cool it was, the next thing I thought was “how can I use these
things in my classroom to enhance learning…” I thought to myself “the screen is big enough to easily
watch a movie, so why not interactive educational material?” If given the chance, my student could
be anywhere in the world as long as there was an internet connection and have
access to content if available. So, I set off on a search to learn more. Here
is a report from my initial
investigations. Could this be an example of a “disruptive innovation”?
I came found a study by Minjuan Wang, Ruimin Shen, Daniel
Novak, and Xiaoyan Pan entitled “The Impact of Mobile Learning On Students’ Learning Behaviours and Performance: Report From a Large Blended Classroom”. In their study, they
set out to determine if cell-phone technology could increase interactivity in a blended
English as an additional language classroom in China. The students had the option to take the class using a
synchronous or asynchronous distance learning method. They soon found that the students enrolled in the live
broadcast weren’t provided with a way to interact with the instructor or with
each other. They feel that
distance learning without interactivity reinforces students’ ability to be
passive learners who don’t (or in this case can’t) participate. Consequently, they developed a program
where students could tune in anywhere and reply instantly with their devices.
Chinese university students are noted as being a bit
reserved, listening quietly to what the instructor has to say. In actuality, this is really no
different than what North American students have been subjected to in lecture
theatres until recent times. The
system was incorporated to engage the students to participate rather than be
passive learners simply watching a lecture on a screen or classroom. Initially, a reward system was used to
further elicit responses. They had
four options for tuning into the class with the text/audio/video option being
most popular (much like our “kitchen parties”). The students would then text in answers to questions posed
by the instructor allowing them to response immediately. Students also had the opportunity to
post messages to a forum and these postings were also analyzed in the study.
The project was deemed as a success on many levels. The
researchers felt that it promoted interaction as well as engaging students
cognitively, socially, and emotionally.
The students were found to have had a high level of satisfaction with
the class, the method of delivery, and with the activities presented to them in
class. The authors present us with
all kinds of statistical data to substantiate their findings.
I could see this being especially useful in the social sciences and
languages. As a mathematics
teacher, I struggle to think of a practical use in my subject area other than for
choosing an answer in a multiple choice format. Perhaps I could be proven wrong. If any teachers have used this technology, I would be
interested to hear your thoughts.
With phones getting more and more technologically advanced, and with
wifi or 4G available in more and more places, hopefully the excuse “I wasn’t
the day we learned this” soon becomes obsolete. My only fear is that this could be seen as a fad and the
interest could soon wane. I intend
to research this topic further.
Check out the study – it’s an interesting read.
Wang,
R. S., Shen, R., Novak, D., & Pan, X. (2009). The impact of mobile learning
on
students’ learning behaviours and performance: Report from
a large blended
classroom. British Journal of Educational Technology, 40(4), 673-695.
doi:10.1111/j.1467-8535.2008.00846.x
Faron, thanks so much for using this space to do an analysis of a research article from BJET and sharing the article with us. I too often hear that there isn't good research available, but that has never been the case for me. I find good, useful research everywhere, and it is great to see that you are on that road too!
ReplyDeleteTurning to the content of the article, I have found much the same thing as the authors: that online learning starts to take on a life when learners can connect cognitively, socially, and emotionally to each other, the instructor, and the content. You might be interested in finding out about Garrison, Anderson and Archer's Community of Inquiry Model (COI), which provides a structure for looking at similar conclusions (http://communitiesofinquiry.com/model). And we have found that for all of this to work, but especially the interpersonal connections, you need to build trust. Sorry for my turgid prose here -- my muse hasn't checked in for work yet this morning.
How did you get Elluminate to work on your iPhone? I've tried it on my iPad and failed miserably, and I'm sure it has to do with the Java applet that must download and install for it to work. Do you have a secret you can share?
Thanks for the post, Rick! As for the watching the kitchen parties on my phone, that was completely staged but I'm sure that the technology will be available soon!!!! I have an android - I will give it a go and see if it can work! I will check out the COI model. Thanks for the info.
ReplyDelete